Xbox One vs Xbox One S: Which Should You Upgrade to in 2024? - Midis

Understanding the Context

Quick Overview: Xbox One vs Xbox One S

| Feature | Xbox One (Original) | Xbox One S |
|-----------------------|---------------------------|--------------------------------|
| Processor | 1.8 GHz AMD Jaguar (8 C') | 1.8 GHz AMD Jaguar (10 C') |
| Memory (RAM) | 8 GB DDR4 | 8 GB DDR4 |
| Storage (HDD) | 500 GB (standard), 1 TB (XL) | 500 GB (standard), 1 TB (XL) |
| Graphics | AMD Radeon HD 8.4 (1.5 Tflops max) | AMD Radeon FlexFX920 (1.65 Tflops max) |
| Shared Storage Storage | 500/1 TB HDD | 500 GB/1 TB SSD (faster load times) |
| Backward Compatibility | Full (Older generations) | Full (Older generations) |
| Online Service | Xbox Live Gold | Xbox Live Gold |
| Price at Launch (2024) | $299 (base model) | $299 (same base) |

Performance: Xbox One S Has a Significant Upgrade

Key Insights

The core reason most recommend upgrading from Xbox One to Xbox One S is performance. The S model delivers:

• Faster CPU: Up to 10 CU Darwin cores boosts processing power, enabling quicker load times, smoother gameplay, and better multitasking.
  
• Higher GPU Clock Speed: The upgraded GPU runs significantly faster, especially important for 4K gaming and sharper textures.
  
• Improved Graphics: The FlexFX920 GPU supports advanced hardware features and faster rendering, critical for 4K and 60fps performance.
  
• Faster Storage (on S models): While basic SSD storage remains 500 GB (no NVMe), the speed improvement from a faster SSD yields noticeably quicker loaded maps and game launches.

For 4K gaming—especially on HDR and high-refresh rates—the Xbox One S delivers a much richer experience compared to the standard Xbox One.

Other Key Differences Relevant to 2024

Final Thoughts

1. Backward Compatibility
Both consoles support backward compatibility, meaning Xbox One games remain playable on the S. This is ideal if you have a large retro library.

2. Price and Value
As of 2024, both configurations start at $299. However, the Xbox One S offers tangible performance gains at no premium price, making it the more cost-effective choice.

3. Multithreading and AI Optimizations
The faster CPU in the Xbox One S benefits modern titles that require strong single- and multi-threaded processing—especially relevant for 2024 releases optimized for next-gen hardware.

4. Limited SSD Storage vs. One X
The S model’s SSD storage (500 GB vs. 1 TB in One X) is a consideration, though 500 GB remains sufficient for hundreds of games. Upgrading storage later is easier with NAS or external options.

Is Upgrading Worth It in 2024?